Naglee Moving & Storage INC
★ 2.4· 14 reviews · Elmira, NY
✓ Licensed (USDOT 15251) ✓ Insured · $750K liability ✓ Cargo covered Active carrier
- USDOT number
- 15251 ↗
- MC number
- MC71262 ↗
- Phone
- (607) 733-4671
- Fleet
- 4 trucks · 7 drivers
- Safety (FMCSA)
- 9 inspections · 4 crashes
- Service area
- Interstate moves
- Location
- 1525 GRAND CENTRAL AVENUE, Elmira, NY 14901
- FMCSA registration updated
- Apr 2026
Contact
- [email protected]
- Mobile
- (717) 599-2885
- Website
- nagleegroup.com
ArtinstallationSelf StorageMovers
Rating trend by year
Share of 1–5★ reviews per year, Google + Yelp combined (15 dated reviews)
1★
2010
1
3★
2012
1
2★
2013
1
5★
2015
1
1★
2016
1
3.7★
2017
3
3★
2018
2
1★
2019
2
1★
2021
1
3★
2026
2
5★
4★
3★
2★
1★
Rating breakdown
2.4
14 reviews total
5
5
4
0
3
1
2
1
1
8
Customer reviews (14)
Yelp
Very rude, after a reservation that was made weeks ago they said an attempt to call and let me know there was no truck available. Never got that message. Save yourself the time and rent a truck from a real truck rental place.
Yelp
Naglee Moving & Storage moved my elderly mother from her home in Ithaca, NY to a retirement community called The Kendell in Ithaca.Tom the driver and his crew were amazing.They packed up everything including her antiques.When they delivered the entire truck, all went perfectly.NO DAMAGE. VERY POLITE...
Yelp
At the time I thought they were great, however when our shipment arrived, many of the boxes were busted, half opened, or just smashed and broken. They didn't wrap any of our couches or our child's beanbag chair. They put my signature on a document I never signed stating the condition of our furnitur...
Yelp
I had an absurdly long review and it was lost so I'm going to boil it down. Pros-Friendly, on time, good communicationCons-Damaged walls, and said it wasn't covered by the contract-Refused to take apart furniture that I paid them for, and asked me to do it while they waited-expensive beyond belief....
Yelp
This was my first time moving with a professional moving company and while I don't have much to compare to, I loved my experience and feel that it's incomparable. Naglee quickly did an in-home estimate that was accurate to the amount of 'stuff' I had, was efficient in packing the day of the move and...
Yelp
Just wanted to update this review because there has been a sequence of events after the posting of the first review that would solidify Naglee and United Van Lines as companies not to deal with. Shelly(sp.) in response to my first review responds by asking me to call her. Optics of this are great es...
We read this company's 5 lowest-rated reviews and sorted what they describe, unverified, as written by the reviewers. A type is listed once two or more reviewers describe it, and a review that describes two problems is counted in both rows. Quotes are the reviewers' own words.
Damaged or lost belongingsItems broken, lost or missing during the move
3 reviews · latest 2021
Damaged or lost belongingsItems broken, lost or missing during the move
3 reviews · latest 2021
“when our shipment arrived, many of the boxes were busted, half opened, or just smashed and broken” 1★ · Yelp · Feb 2021 · Mandy T. · See this company on Yelp →
“Damaged walls, and said it wasn't covered by the contract” 1★ · Yelp · Dec 2019 · James M. · See this company on Yelp →
“when we unpacked upon arrival, there was $1,000s in damage. The items damaged were irreplaceable.” 1★ · Yelp · Nov 2010 · Alex R. · See this company on Yelp →
These are customers' accounts, quoted as written. Problem types and sums are our reading of each review. We do not verify individual claims, and the company may dispute them. Counts cover the 5 low-rated reviews we read, not every review on Google or Yelp. Bars compare the types with each other.
Write a review
Log in to write a review →Profile views
Daily visits to this profile over the last 30 days (24 total)
Sep 6
Oct 5